jp.jpg (13389 bytes)

CHAOS MANOR MAIL

Mail 129 November 27 - December 3, 2000

read book now

HOME

VIEW

MAIL

Columns

BOOK Reviews

emailblimp.gif (23130 bytes)mailto:jerryp@jerrypournelle.com

CLICK ON THE BLIMP TO SEND MAIL TO ME

  The current page will always have the name currentmail.html and may be bookmarked. For previous weeks, go to the MAIL HOME PAGE.

FOR THE CURRENT VIEW PAGE CLICK HERE

If you are not paying for this place, click here...

IF YOU SEND MAIL it may be published; if you want it private SAY SO AT THE TOP of the mail. I try to respect confidences, but there is only me, and this is Chaos Manor. If you want a mail address other than the one from which you sent the mail to appear, PUT THAT AT THE END OF THE LETTER as a signature.

I try to answer mail, but mostly I can't get to all of it. I read it all, although not always the instant it comes in. I do have books to write too...  I am reminded of H. P. Lovecraft who slowly starved to death while answering fan mail. 

Day-by-day...
Monday -- Tuesday -- Wednesday -- Thursday -- Friday -- Saturday -- Sunday
 
atomz search

Search: type in string and press return.

 

or the freefind search

 
   Search this site or the web        powered by FreeFind
 
  Site search Web search


Boiler Plate:

If you want to PAY FOR THIS there are problems, but I keep the latest HERE. I'm trying. MY THANKS to all of you who sent money.  Some of you went to a lot of trouble to send money from overseas. Thank you! There are also some new payment methods. I am preparing a special (electronic) mailing to all those who paid: there will be a couple of these. I am also toying with the notion of a subscriber section of the page. LET ME KNOW your thoughts.
.

If you subscribed:

atom.gif (1053 bytes) CLICK HERE for a Special Request.

If you didn't and haven't, why not?

If this seems a lot about paying think of it as the Subscription Drive Nag. You'll see more.

Highlights this week:

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Search: type in string and press return.

 

LAST WEEK                                                               NEXT WEEK

line6.gif (917 bytes)

 
This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

TOP

Monday  November 27, 2000

I have been under the weather. Skip to Wednesday.

 

 

TOP

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

TOP

Tuesday

 

TOP

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

TOP

Wednesday, November 29, 2000

Today I try to catch up with nearly a week's worth of selected mail. I'll see what I can do about organizing it, but it's going to be Short Shrift indeed. By the way, I got that wonderful phrase from Steve Allen a very long time ago, on one of the programs he hosted. With that wonderful sincerity of his he looked at a guest, pointed out that the time was late, and said, "Well, for you, we have -- short shrift." I laughed like crazy. That must have been 30 years ago. Steve Allen was a gentleman, and one of the most interesting conversationalists I know of. In fact his program, "Conversation", featuring characters from history put into a panel discussion, with Jayne playing Marie Antoinette once, and Lucretia Borgia another time, was wonderful. He also used to have Jacques Barzun as a regular. Anyone who can appreciate Jacques Barzun, and did so for the last 40 years, has to have been more of an intellectual than all the talking heads I see on TV now put together.

I missed Steve Allen's good sense after he stopped being a regular. He and Jayne were great as guests in a "Homicide" episode a few years ago. This nation could use a lot more like him in the "entertainment industry".


I am afraid a picture that was on a website ( www.mcarthurweb.com )  that I got to from a link that was on your page has given me and my colleagues just too much fun!

Maybe some folks there may get the same amount of amusement.

--- _._ Dominick A. Trascritti, "Cogito Ergo Swoon"

Dear Dr. Pournelle, I was reading "Windows NT Security" written by Charles B. Rutstein (for the National Computer Security Association, McGraw Hill 1997) on the topic of... securing an NT install. On page 103 under "Trojan Horse Attacks" the author lays out a scenario for an attack that replaces a common Windows utility with a dummy that forwards all input to the real utility. The utility used was, of course, Notepad. The particular example had to do with administrators needing to A) use NTFS, and B) change the default permissions for systems utilities so that a non-Administrator can't change these common files. Sad to say that the author's assertion that this type of attack was almost impossible to resist came true.

Cheers, Warren Pettingell

Yes and it gets worse. We are now convinced that the Trojan got into Chaos Manor through my wife's modem connection, and drifted from there to machines linked to hers through our LAN. That bypassed the security of my Linux box, which I think remains secure so far. 


In Washington state they recently switched to a new ballot system. Formerly, the state used punched cards, with chads and all; now they use a system that is much better.

A ballot is a very stiff piece of paper (or maybe a very thin sheet of cardboard) with ovals printed next to candidate names. Using a black pen, the voter colors in the oval. The ballot is about the size of a sheet of office paper (8.5" x 11") so there is lots of room and no need for weird butterfly ballots; also both sides can be used. No special "Votamatic" machines are needed; small stand-up privacy-screened desks are available for the voters to use.

After a voter is done voting, the ballot is fed into a counting machine. The machine immediately scores the ballot. If the voter has voted for multiple names in one position (e.g. both Bush and Gore for President), the machine kicks the ballot back out... and the voter gets a chance to do it over! When a ballot is accepted, it is counted by the machine and falls into a storage box under the machine.

When the polls close, they take the machines, hook them up to phone lines, and the machines report the vote tally to the main computers.

Note that no matter how many times a ballot is handled, black ink marks will not fall off or mysteriously appear. I'll bet you could recount these ballots over and over and get pretty much the same result each time. (This will be tested soon, as there will be an automatic recount in the Senator race between Gorton and Cantwell.)

This system is so close to perfect that I cannot imagine ways to improve on it. Easy to use, quick to score the results, robust in recounting. I fear any kind of Internet-based or computer-based voting system; I want it to be as hard as possible to steal an election.

P.S. This system has been used in two election years now. The first time, they gave us permanent "Sharpie" felt tip markers, and I have never voted so quickly in my life! This year they gave us ordinary black ball-point ink pens, and it was more work to color in the ovals completely. Next time I'm bringing my own Sharpie. -- Steve R. Hastings "Vita est" steve@hastings.org http://www.blarg.net/~steveha

Seems very sensible to me. I have always been a bit wary of punched card -- the first time they were objected to was in the 1964 election when they were said to have confused Goldwater voters in Orange County, then heavily Republican. There was no recount, I think. And when I managed the Yorty campaign for Mayor of LA, I had some computer savvy people go down and examine the counting programs since all it would take would be assigning 10% of unpunched ballots -- there are usually a lot of them -- to the other guy to change the election. Something well known to anyone who studies the problem. A lot of people do not vote for the top of the ticket. Who knows why? They never admit it in exit polls, although they will sometimes tell you privately. "Never vote. It only encourages them."


I understand McAfee virus signature update 4102 which Network Associates calls a .DAT file is a resource hog when Virus Scan is run resident. Published solution is use a newer one.

I understand changes beyond the virus signature which NETWORK ASSOCIATES calls a SuperDat are not necessarily cumulative as explained in the SuperDat readme file. Therefore the SuperDat can update some files which are then not compatible with existing old files. This will require a boot to safemode or otherwise accessing the system to adjust the files or disable load on startup. Some combinations will produce a blue screen of death. The readme file suggests appropriate adjustments if the readme is read after installing but before rebooting when reading the readme becomes an easy option (if not previously read from the website by itself).

I might criticize Network Associates on this, but instead I will praise them for a business model that continues free signature support but not indefinite free software version update for quite some time after retail sale or distribution even though it means supporting many variations of the software. If there were no new sales then all support goes away for everybody, but even without new sales there is extended support. I was confused by the McAfee site discussion of search engines for version 4X and version 5X of the software myself.

Personally I deal with the security and convenience issues by going dual boot on distinct physical drives - just as many machines are now dual bios for backup - so I may be able to easily manipulate files without loading from a panic disk or maybe not. I keep McAfee on one operating system and Norton System Works on the other - not asking them to play nice together.

Switching to operating systems, I notice a pendulum swing in Linux office suites and user shells. Reminds me of DOS 15+ years ago when there were shells like Top View and Geo competing with the nascent Windows. Similarly there is now an effort to associate shells and office suites in Linux distributions rather than make everything work together and allow full user choice. Speaking of user choice I hear lots of Windows 2000 installations in the enterprise are being locked down with the user denied administrator or super-user rights on the person's own assigned machine. ASP as a return to the glass house anyone?

Clark

As I understand it, McAfee is the old Dr. Solomon virus detection system. I had not known this; I thought Alan Solomon was bought out by OnTrack, but the OnTrack people said to me at COMDEX that it was McAfee who now had the Solomon engine. Does anyone actually know? Solomon's was the best of the lot, but of course part of that was his tenacity in analyzing new viruses as they came out; they were always the first with detection and fixes for new infections.

Using both McAfee and Norton System Works (but not on the same  machine) is probably a good idea. I need to think about it but my first impression is, yeah, why not? Good way to have a new string for your bow.


Dr. Pournelle:

At the Hubble Space Telescope Science Institute's webpage, under the Heritage Archive Images by Subject( http://oposite.stsci.edu/pubinfo/subject.html  ) there is a link entitled, " A Mote In Hubble's Eye."

Can't imagine where they came up with that.... :-J

V/R

Steven

Heh. Thanks.


Jerry, You mentioned:

"It will be an interesting test to see (1) how many subscribers read this and say something, and (2) how many new subscribers I get who cite this possibility as the reason for subscribing."

I spend a lot of time here because of the views presented, both about computers and national or world issues. Not everything interests me, but a significant portion (probably 80% or more) does, and I'm very willing to pay to:

1. Get Dr. Pournelle's views, as I respect your accomplishments, clear thinking, and desire to present both sides of the story. 

2. Get the perspectives of others who lurk here, as they tend to be intelligent, clear thinking, and typically with differing opinions, but rarely express them to others in a demeaning way, although I realize and appreciate that you sanitize that a bit before we see it, Jerry. 

3. Participate in the discussions myself.

I read Byte to get input, but post my responses to Byte articles here. The same would most likely be true for new Intellectual Capital articles, or any other venue.

Tracy Walters

Thanks. I put yours up as representative of most of what was said. And I seem to have a wave of new subscribers. I have, I hope, got to acknowledging all of them, but I haven't done a decent mailing in a while. Real Soon Now I guess...


And sort of related to that:

Jerry,

I'm slowly learning my way around Chaos Manor, and I must say that the more I see, the more I like. Book reviews, space tech. updates, social commentary, ARR, ARR, ARR! (the Tim Allen "Home Improvement" grunt)

Trademarked grendels??? Who do these folks think they're kidding? I didn't get to Beowulf until a 9th grade British Lit. course, but the public schools were already in decline by 1980. (BTW, any plans for Beowulf's Grandchildren?)

If you think there's trouble over the anthrax vaccine in the ranks of the Active component of our armed forces, just wait until the Foggy Bottom Folk get around to trying it on the Reserves. I'm currently at 16.5 years, and am an E-7 infantry Drill Sergeant. Career reservist: 2 months active duty for "boot camp" (1984 summer vacation between 11th and 12th grade of high school) 2 months active for infantry school (after HS graduation) and two months active (stateside) during the gulf war. Things sure have changed.

Website recommendations:

www.tighar.org  is the site for The International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery. I like these guys so much that I joined. Great site, well laid out and easy to navigate. Earhart Project section has FAQs, current research bulletins, LOTS of pics, AND puts a tidy end to all the various conspiracy theories that've been lurking about for 60+ years.

www.constitutionparty.com  is the website for (duh) the Constitution Party. (formerly the US Taxpayers Party) This might be especially popular given the chaotic current state of politics. If "libertarians with morals" seems a contradiction, then just think of them as being libertarian in thought, but with an eye towards reversing the attendant tendency towards hedonism that Roger Elwood mentioned in the tales of New America all those years ago. As an extra plus, their most recent presidential candidate was Howard Phillips, who claims to have been involved in SDI from the very beginning, and is a huge advocate for a space based missile defense.

www.oakislandtreasure.com  is the site for pics and anecdotes about Oak Island, Nova Scotia. That's the place mentioned in those public school 6th grade weekly readers back in the late 1970's where there's a pit dating to the late 1700's that fills up with water whenever excavation is attempted and is thought to contain cleverly boobytrapped pirate treasure. The story was recently fictionalized in the rip roaring adventure novel Riptide by Douglas Preston. I rank it right up there with Steven Pressfield's "Gates of Fire" as one of the best non-SF novels I've read in the past year.

Sorry for being so wordy Doc; blame my folks- they taught me to read when I was 4, and I've been loving it ever since. Anyway, you have a great site which I have recommended to lots of friends. Thanks, keep up the great work, and Happy Thanksgiving.

Dave Porter, Lincoln Park, MI 

I recall reading about Oak Island when I was in high school, and being fascinated with it ever since. But then my great grandfather McKinney actually got some of Lafitte's treasure, with which he bought the Florida East Coast Railway system which my grandfather managed for him out of Fort White. A very long time ago, but it's why my mother graduated from Florida State Normal School in Gainseville.

Gates of Fire is pretty realistic. There are parts I'd quarrel with. But I confess I am not entirely rational on the subject. Standing there on the knoll and knowing you are standing at the Grave of the Three Hundred does that to you. Or did to me.


Hi Jerry,

Have you tried the Google search engine? I use it almost exclusively now.

They allow you to use their engine on your web site for searching for information. You might want to have a look at it some day.

Google http://www.google.com 

There is a spot on the bottom blue bar "Add Google to your site"

- Paul pdwalker@quagmyre.com

Indeed I think I do want to look at it some day. When I get a Round Tuit. Which is when I recover from this crud and catch up. But I have heard good things about it before.


Jerry,

I have recently had to move our office into the third bedroom (box? room - 8' x 5') to allow our daughter to have some more space as she is now hitting those teenage years.

For the first time I have had to deal with seriously packing away lots of things and storing them in the loft, so I can at least move around in the new office.

I realised pretty soon that I needed to minimise all of the hardware. Not only this but the noise from the running equipment is terrible in such a small area.

Have you ever tried to find out if anyone sells cases that are diminutive in size, that muffle the sound from the internals efficiently, and contain whisper quiet power supplies ?

The ideal piece of hardware that comes to mind is the Apple G4 Cube, but I need an x86 PC format machine.

I have mailed many different manufacturers regarding this issue and have had little success.

Have you ever considered running an article on this subject ? Or do you know of any companies that build cases relatively small, with a greater thickness to the structure and containing a quiet power supply ?

Regards,

Matthew Soul

UK

I confess I live with considerable fan noise and it doesn't much bother me; it's "white noise" to me, and I soon tune it out. But then I have been partially deaf since 1950.


I think this was more a press release than a letter but I saved it anyway:

In case you get this message and it interests you. There is a company by the name of Interface Security http://www.keyghost.com/securekb.htm  that makes a suite of products called KeyGhost. It's a simple hardware keyloging system.

I know that writers are paranoiac about loosing their work. They offer 2 kind of products, a keyboard pass though that you put between your keyboard and your PC or an integrated product that consists of a keyboard with the Keyghost hardware.

As a "backup" tool for writers it could be invaluable....

Good Luck!

Vick Sweeney Quebec, Canada

On this one I plead "ignoramus". My backup consists of saving everything in a lot of places, early and often.


Greetings Jerry!

Always enjoy(ed) reading your column (now and in the [alas!] now gone BYTE magazine.) Yours was the first column I read in the magazine each time I received it.

Thought you might like to know that your column [#241] on the QAZ virus/Soyo motherboards had an error in one of the links. You mention both the SOYO motherboard and the BTC-DVD drive and give separate links. They can BOTH be accessed at the SOYO link. The link given for the BTC (www.btc.com) is for (are your ready?) Oriental (Chinese?) site named "Brain Trust Company" that lists PORNO Videos!!! Whoops!

Just thought you'd like to know.

Cheers, Rudy -- rwengjen@WestminsterResearch.com 

 "The beige box is around because it's an industrial product. There's no value added by making it look like a banana." Mark Bregman - IBM

Oops! I think that has been fixed...


I think that one of the tips floating around is to turn of System Restore in Windows Me in order to reclaim the CPU cycles and resources associtated with it.

This is done from the System Control Panel, Performance Tab, File System Button, Troubleshooting Tab, and it is the bottom option on the menu.

But once you have disabled the "feature", the next question is.. What does one use to replace the functionality with?

I listen to a local radio show here on Saturday's on WPHL 1210am called the Computer Show.

The moderator Rich Levin, has written a couple of great programs (ala Steve Gibson) which address this.

He has a program called WinBak which is currently in a 1.0 version, and works on Windows 95/98/Me with a new version about to be release shortly.

It is currently listed as shareware, but I believe he intends to release the next version as freeware..

He also makes a program called Space Ace III, which is a disk cleaning program that purports to clean up unwanted files from the hard drive. I haven't used this yet, so I can't comment..

But I use WinBak and run it every couple of days, or just before I've installed something new..

The website address is:

http://www.rblevin.net 

I can't say I agree with all the advice he dispenses on the show, but this program is useful..

Regards, Al Hartman http://www.geocities.com/alhartman 

Join the Macintosh Emulation List... http://www.topica.com/lists/Macemulist

Enlightenment means taking full responsibility for your life. - William Blake

I have not noticed any reason to "speed up" things, but I have not bothered to "upgrade" older systems to ME, and all the new ones with ME on them are 900+ MHz systems: the hardware is fast enough that no "speed up" would even be noticed.

I now have a bunch of Intel Pentium III systems from 750 to 1.5 gig and it's pretty hard to tell the differences among them...


Dear Jerry,

In your Comdex Wrap-up article at www.byte.com, you wrote "The only real problem with CompactFlash is that it's almost too small; it's hard to keep track of a device that's about the size of a thick postage stamp. Lexar gave me a special wallet to keep mine in, but that's too big. What I need is a shirt-pocket CompactFlash holder." May I suggest a compact flash PC Card adapter. I know Lexar makes them; I'm sure others do also. Obviously it is the size of a PC Card, sturdy, and you can access images from your camera on your laptop without messing with cables. Plus, if your laptop sees these devices as a drive, a simple batch file could transfer images to the hard drive with a double click, handy when you are taking a lot of pictures quickly. You shoud be able to find one for about US $10.

Greg French Greenwood Nova Scotia Canada

Yes, I wrote about those in my PCEXPO coverage last summer. But I don't think carrying one of those card converters for each Compact Flash is the right answer. Still they do fit in a shirt pocket and they are cheap. Thanks.


Jerry,

I am using an optical Microsoft IntelliMouse on my Belkin KVM switch with no problems at all! I have discarded all of my ball mice by now, hate them!

Anker

Yes, I am using optical mice with both Belkin and ICU-124 KVM switches now, and I have no problems with them at all. Can't think why I said they didn't work; sheer lag, and I think I really mean with Spirit an ancient server.

Jerry:

I recently tried all the KVM switches available from my distributor (TechData) to see if I could find one that would support the thumb button on my 4-button Logitech mouse. None could, and phone calls to the support organizations confirmed that (I should have called in the first place, instead of buying one of everything!).

Along the way I discovered something: the Linksys KVM switch is (other than front panel) identical to the Belkin, and is less than *HALF* the price of the Belkin.

Also, for your personal fund of knowledge, the Cybex "Switchview" KVM's will work nicely with the opticals you called "red light" mice.

Hope this helps,

Tom Keiser

Hmm. thanks.

Jerry,

You've given a strong endorsement of Belkin KVM switches in recent week. I wanted to make sure that you got some feedback on that. Over the last year, I have (through my workplace) owned approximately 40 Belkin switches, from 8-port pro models to 2- and 4-port ones. I have experienced approximately 30% failure over 6 months. They seem pretty good to start with, but sooner later, the switching features fail on one port or another. Additionally, even on Belkins that haven't suffered a permanent disability, I've noticed a number of mouse disconnects and occasional keyboard disconnects. (By disconnect, I mean the thing doesn't work until you power cycle everything)

The Belin switches may be better than cheapo switches (in the <$50 range), but they aren't all that good. If you're serious, I recommend buying a Cybex or Apex switch. The swiching speed is faster, the video doesn't have ghosting that you sometimes see on a Belkin, and they don't fail quite so much. I believe it's a false economy to buy a $500 switch that's going to fail when you can buy a $1000 switch that you will love.

And as an added plus, my Cybex Autoview 200 doesn't make that loud clicking sound every time you switch. (Not to mention that you can hook up two consoles to share the 8 servers connected to the switch)

I love your column and value your insights.

Thanks, Josh

I can only say that I have been using Belkin KVM switches for over a year without any problems of any kind. But then the only problem I had with the ICS switches was its inability to pass video from one machine. I still don't understand that one. But the Belkin solved that problem. If I have difficulties I will report them, but in fact the Belkin units have work quite well.



Jerry

Interested to read your reactions to EDS's advertising at Comdex. I'm surprised you haven't been aware of them before; EDS is probably best known outside the tech world for being the means by which Ross Perot became wealthy enough to contest the US presidential race as an independent. I am told (and it may be apocryphal) that in the days when he ran the firm (which I believe he founded) the office walls were covered with Big Brother-esque posters of Perot exhorting his staff to work harder.

I'd be wary of pronouncing on the quality of the post-Perot EDS based on their PR at a show; they've been involved in several high-profile failures of IT projects for the UK government in recent years.

regards

Martin Smith

This communication is for informational purposes only. It is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument or as an official confirmation of any transaction. All market prices, data and other information are not warranted as to completeness or accuracy and are subject to change without notice. Any comments or statements made herein do not necessarily reflect those of J.P. Morgan &; Co. Incorporated, its subsidiaries and affiliates.

Actually I was told that was Perot's old outfit, but I wasn't at all sure what THAT had actually done; it operated in places well beyond my Micro world.

They sure spent money on good will at COMDEX.


This was over in VIEW but it is worth repeating. It is wonderful:

Jerry: This is an incredible image of the earth at night. Scroll over and look at the difference between North and South Korea!

Regards, Chris C

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/image/0011/earthlights_dmsp_big.jpg 


Dear Dr. Pournelle, When trying to upgrade a W98 installation to a W98 Second Edition installation - for a friend who is not too computer literate - the process apparently worked but the modem -an old model- refused to make a connection saying there was no dial tone. On trying to reinstall the modem drivers the setup program demanded the Win98 S.E. CD and then began to give a series of file not found messages. The file names were "fileexfer.cnt", "fileexfer.exe", "fileexfer.hlp", "fet.dll", "wexe32.dll" and "wsw.vxd". The setup program seems to think that these files should be in the CAB file named "PRECOPY1.CAB". Searching that file with EXTRACT produced no problems but no sign of these files. The CD in question was purchased at the MS store by my friend's son who is works at MS. Two other friends at my request searched the "PRECOPY1.CAB" file in their CDs - locally bought from MS agents - with the same negative results. The supplier of the modem supplied a driver disk that got the modem working, but even after this, every time the machine was started it would try to install a driver for the modem and report the same files missing. A second reinstall with the W 98 S.E. CD with the new modem driver disk solved this problem. and the machine boots ok now. This was last week yesterday another friend ran into the same problem as he was upgradeing his machine to W98 SE. There was no modem on this one but the scanner -again an old one- wouldn't work. Again a reinstall with new drivers solved the problem. There seems to be something wrong or at least incomplete with W98 S.E. installer. It looks as if when it cant find appropriate drivers it expects to find generic drivers or some other help in these files - only the files are not there. Does anyone know what is happening here? Yours sinecerly Ramesh Nayar

 

Apologies but I can't read this. You sent html to me, and outlook doesn't seem to know how to paste special to make it work. To All: the proper format is do nothing except be sure to double space between paragraphs and where you want a real line break. That works, and is easy for me to deal with;


And one I have not had a chance to look at (and also formatted impossibly):

Dr. Pournelle, >From the CNN website, also reported by CBS News: http://www.cnn.com/2000/HEALTH/11/27/gulfwar.brain.reut/index.html 

George Laiacona III <george@eisainc.com> ICQ 37042478/ 28885038 "You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time...and that should be enough to get you through." "You can kill some of the people all of the time, and you can kill all of the people some of the time, but you can't kill all of the people all of the time...because then who'll grow the food?" -Excerpts, King's Men Political Manual


To: Jerry Pournelle From: Chris Morton Subj: Military Ballots in Florida

Dear Dr. Pournelle:

Here's a bit of preemptive advice for you if anyone ever complains to you that the Palm Beach canvassing board didn't have enough time to do the manual recount and should have been granted an extension.

Just ask them if the crew of the USS Cole took Thanksgiving off the way the Palm Beach canvassing board did.

Chris Morton Rocky River, Ohio

That requires no comment. Thank you.


Dr. P:

For the nearly 30 years we've been together my wife has eschewed science fiction.

A couple of months ago she was desperate for a book to read, so I somehow convinced her to try the Mote. Low and behold, she thoroughly enjoyed it.

Last night I was reading to her the very succinct and well done description of the malaria organism (Plasmodium falciparum) in the 20 October issue of Science (Vol. 290, box on p. 435). About two thirds of the way through she exclaimed: "Moties!"

Regards,

PMP

Great! Thanks. Greg Bear tells me the next big technology breakthroughs will be in biological engineering and I believe him.


(Regarding social sciences) Jerry,

Haven't given much thought to any of this for a while, but it does recall for me the two usefull things I retained from a brief stint as an interdisciplinary social science major. The first from an introductory class professor:

"Clinical psychology is akin to tarot cards and astrology."

The second as an intro to a statistics book:

"Statistics is a body of methods for making wise decisions in the face of uncertainty."

Both have served me well. I don't remember much of the rest. Thanks for being here, stay well.

Paul rphampson@earthlink.net

I have no quarrel with either of those aphorisms. It is precisely the lack of real statistical analysis, particularly Bayesian analysis of the value of more information prior to acting in Global Warming, that is one of our largest problems. We KNOW HOW to make proper decisions in the face of uncertainty, and we can determine whether we ought to ACT NOW or GATHER MORE INFORMATION given the probabilities we already have and the payoffs positive and negative from acting or not acting NOW. These are straightforward Bayesian analysis and with modern computers it's easy to solve those equations.

But no one does it, and the politicians yammer and yammer.


You might want to be aware that there are at least two nice freeware programs called Notepad+ whose executables are called notepad.exe, and are over 100K. Usually they are in their own directories though, not Windows.

>>To find out if you have been hit by QAZ, do a search for filenames and folders containing the word note. Now click on "size" in the result so that they are sorted in reverse order, largest files first. Look at NOTEPAD.EXE, and if that file is larger than 100K you have been infected, and you will probably find a file called NOTE.COM that will be about 50K (depending on which version of Windows you run). The presence of NOTEPAD.EXE larger than 100K is the real clue. <<

I fear I sent a rather impolite reply to this beginning "You might want to be aware that Notepad.exe is a copyrighted program and it is almost never a good idea to replace programs distributed with the operating system; better to give the "replacement" it's own name and change the associations accordingly."

Which is still true. And I say again, if you have a Notepad.exe file larger than 100K you are probably in trouble; if you have replaced the notepad.exe Microsoft sent with your own, you are on your own, but are you SURE that the one you put is is the one that is still there?

I should apologize for the irritated tone I took with my correspondent, though. 


Mr. Pournelle,

Have you played Everquest since the upgrade to DX7.0a? If so, have you had any problems with the sound on any of your machines? I know I've played the game since it came out in March or April of 1999, and have had nothing but problems with the sound since the major patch before last. I was just reading one of the EQ boards, and found out that I'm not the only one to have this issue.

Here's the link to the message board: http://boards.station.sony.com/everquest/Forum1/HTML/005635.html 

There was only one reply back from a moderator on this and his reply was a threat to quit moderating this message board. I'm very disappointed with the poor quality of customer service that they are giving to their paying customers.

I'm writing this in hopes to bring some media attention to the issue and hopefully get Variant to give us players some answer.

Thank you for you time,

Jim Ramsey Sr. Systems Engineer Viva.com http://www.viva.com 

I have had no problems with sound, but I continue to be irritated by being killed while inside an Inn with the door closed. Apparently some players were "running into inns" to escape monsters, and the omniscient gamesmasters decided that was a form of cheating.

Now in the real world, and innkeepers who operated in places with monsters would, I suppose, take care to defend their customers. They might charge them money for that, but how is it "cheating" to run to a place of refuge to escape being killed? While I understand the concern about "cheating" given the experiences on Diablo multi-player networks, this is quite different.

Another example that annoys me: Varant has decided that since some people cut off their machines to escape death, they will allow you to be killed even though it is their servers being overloaded and dropping you off that caused the disconnection. There are fairly heavy penalties associated with suddenly being "link-dead" (including loss of many magical items), and these are applied whether this is voluntary by the player or imposed on him by the inadequacies of the Everquest hardware. This is the kind of arrogance that loses customers. So far they seem to have escaped the wrath many of us feel, but I suspect that competition may change some of that. 

If players not involved in player vs player contests seek to escape the consequences of their actions by volutary reset of the machine, thus losing many minutes of play and having tediously to restore the connection, why must those who did not do this be penalized just because the Everquest programmers can't figure out how to differentiate between voluntary disconect and the failure of their own hardware?

Sure. Their servers get overloaded. That in itself makes play painful sometimes. Why in the world must they impose their view of "what is enjoyable" on their customers? Heck, if someone wants to "cheat" by resetting his system before being killed by monsters, (in essence feigning death) that doesn't hurt ME, nor do I see how it harms Everquest in general. And I certainly do not see how it is "cheating" to run into a building in the game in the expectation that when you are inside with the door closed lions cannot come in with you...

But I have had no problems with sound.


I'm sure that you and many of you readers have seen this poem before, but it never hurts to read it again to remind us of the sacrifices some make for their country. This is for my Dad and everyone else who has served... Thanks.

'TWAS THE NIGHT BEFORE CHRISTMAS, HE LIVED ALL ALONE, IN A ONE BEDROOM HOUSE MADE OF PLASTER AND STONE.

I HAD COME DOWN THE CHIMNEY WITH PRESENTS TO GIVE, AND TO SEE JUST WHO IN THIS HOME DID LIVE.

I LOOKED ALL ABOUT, A STRANGE SIGHT I DID SEE, NO TINSEL, NO PRESENTS, NOT EVEN A TREE.

NO STOCKING BY MANTLE, JUST BOOTS FILLED WITH SAND, ON THE WALL HUNG PICTURES OF FAR DISTANT LANDS.

WITH MEDALS AND BADGES, AWARDS OF ALL KINDS, A SOBER THOUGHT CAME THROUGH MY MIND.

FOR THIS HOUSE WAS DIFFERENT, IT WAS DARK AND DREARY, I FOUND THE HOME OF A SOLDIER, ONCE I COULD SEE CLEARLY.

THE SOLDIER LAY SLEEPING, SILENT, ALONE, CURLED UP ON THE FLOOR IN THIS ONE BEDROOM HOME.

THE FACE WAS SO GENTLE, THE ROOM IN SUCH DISORDER, NOT HOW I PICTURED A UNITED STATES SOLDIER.

WAS THIS THE HERO OF WHOM I'D JUST READ? CURLED UP ON A PONCHO, THE FLOOR FOR A BED?

I REALIZED THE FAMILIES THAT I SAW THIS NIGHT, OWED THEIR LIVES TO THESE SOLDIERS WHO WERE WILLING TO FIGHT.

SOON ROUND THE WORLD, THE CHILDREN WOULD PLAY, AND GROWNUPS WOULD CELEBRATE A BRIGHT CHRISTMAS DAY.

THEY ALL ENJOYED FREEDOM EACH MONTH OF THE YEAR, BECAUSE OF THE SOLDIERS, LIKE THE ONE LYING HERE.

I COULDN'T HELP WONDER HOW MANY LAY ALONE, ON A COLD CHRISTMAS EVE IN A LAND FAR FROM HOME.

THE VERY THOUGHT BROUGHT A TEAR TO MY EYE, I DROPPED TO MY KNEES AND STARTED TO CRY.

THE SOLDIER AWAKENED AND I HEARD A ROUGH VOICE, "SANTA DON'T CRY, THIS LIFE IS MY CHOICE;

I FIGHT FOR FREEDOM, I DON'T ASK FOR MORE, MY LIFE IS MY GOD, MY COUNTRY, MY CORPS."

THE SOLDIER ROLLED OVER AND DRIFTED TO SLEEP, I COULDN'T CONTROL IT, I CONTINUED TO WEEP.

I KEPT WATCH FOR HOURS, SO SILENT AND STILL AND WE BOTH SHIVERED FROM THE COLD NIGHT'S CHILL.

I DIDN'T WANT TO LEAVE ON THAT COLD, DARK, NIGHT, THIS GUARDIAN OF HONOR SO WILLING TO FIGHT.

THEN THE SOLDIER ROLLED OVER, WITH A VOICE SOFT AND PURE, WHISPERED, "CARRY ON SANTA, IT'S CHRISTMAS DAY, ALL IS SECURE."

ONE LOOK AT MY WATCH, AND I KNEW HE WAS RIGHT. "MERRY CHRISTMAS MY FRIEND, AND TO ALL A GOOD NIGHT."

This poem was written by a Marine stationed in Okinawa Japan. The following is his request. I think it is reasonable.....

PLEASE. Would you do me the kind favor of sending this to as many people as you can? Christmas will be coming soon and some credit is due to our U.S. service men and women for our being able to celebrate these festivities.

===== Chris Levesque clevesqu@yahoo.com

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." -- U.S. Declaration of Independence

 


TOP

 

 

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

read book now

TOP

Thursday, November 30, 2000

Mr. Dennis Prager, writing in the Wall Street Journal, has written what amounts to a declaration of war on Democrats. It should be available to those who are not subscribers to the Journal at:

http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=65000704 

-- Cheers! - Lindy Sisk Lindy@arcanamavens.com

"Early retirement is like a second childhood with no parental supervision."

Mr. Praeger is a local talk show radio host. He speaks rather strongly, but he makes a point. Perhaps it is not as much to rejoice about as he thinks. But perhaps it is.

 

Dear Jerry,

We would like to thank you for signing up for EarthLink Broadband service. This exciting new product represents the future of Internet access, and we are pleased that you chose EarthLink to bring it to you.

Your phone number 818xxxxxxxx is being provisioned for DSL. After 5:00pm on your service activation date 11/29/00, you can proceed with the self-installation process. If you have any questions, or have not received your two kits: Self Installation Kit (hardware) and EarthLink Welcome Kit (software) within two days prior to your service activation date, please call us at (888) 829-8466.

As part of our commitment to deliver the high-quality service our customers expect, we have also provided special self-install instructions on our website at: http://www.EarthLink.net/dsl/install_info

Again, thanks for choosing EarthLink Broadband Service. We hope you enjoy the super-fast DSL speed, the always-on connection, and our award-winning customer support with your EarthLink Broadband account. Faster access is just the beginning!

Sincerely,

EarthLink Broadband

I would shout for joy except that as of Noon November 30 the light continues to blink and I cannot lock on to a DSL line.

 

 

 

 

 

 

TOP

 

 

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

TOP

Friday, December 1, 2000

I have put a somewhat partisan but as far as I can see accurate description of the Republican "riot" on a separate page since it is partisan and it's a bit long. One might contrast it with Jesse Jackson's earlier demonstrations. Or not. Thanks to Trent Telenko.


For what it is worth, at my compnay we have had endless problems with Belkin Omniviews - the motherboard we use (intel with nic and video built in) seem to try an auto sense where your mouse is, and if you dont have the machine selevted for viewing when it boots, then the sense fails. On Windows this results in no mouse upon boot. On linux it often results in a hung boot.

Both intel and Belkin did not respond to complaints. We're gradually replacing all the Belkins with Apex Outlook's (which are also smaller, but do have custom cablesets).

-s

I may have neglected to say that I usually bring up servers in order and watch as they come up rather than firing them up without watching. I have workstations on KVM and those I will turn on without selecting them; they seem to work all right. Servers I am more particular about. But then I seldom turn them off, either.


Jerry,

I took Thanksgiving Week to go deer hunting in Saskatchewan, when I returned my mail system on my work PC was corrupted. I was running Netscape 4.7/Communicator. It turns out that there is a limit on the size of mail files in Netscape. When you reach it, you can no longer open them. In my case, I can't get into the inbox.

Right now I am running Netscape 6, and it is a proper piglet. I am going to commission the wizards upstairs to build me a new machine; I thought I would ask what you and RBT would recommend. I will buy the book, but it is not here now.

I need a PC which will last about 3 years. I do MS office things mostly, but do a lot of research on the net. I don't play games at all. Right now I am running an Intel 166 MHz Pentium with 32 megs of RAM and 6 GByte hard drives; CD-ROM, Zip, floppy. I will be running IE and Outlook Express on the new box, I use them at home on my Mac G3.

Thanks for any help...jim dodd Subscriber

The short answer is use an Intel P III of 600 or more, on an Intel D815EEAL motherboard. This will take care of everything and if later you really want high end graphics you can put an AGP board in, but the built in graphics on the motherboard are good enough. It's hard to get hard disks with less than 10 gigabytes, but in fact I'd get more. They're $5 a gig up to about 30 and that ought to be enough. Get 128 megs memory and put Windows 2000 Professional on it.

Bob Thompson adds that you need a backup capability: either tape, or a Plextor Plexwriter CD-RW, one of the latest with BurnProof. I would also add Nero, Burning ROM software, although with the new Plexwriter hardware almost anything will do.

This is the sort of thing you will find in our book. When we get it done. Until then get Thompson's Hardware In A Nutshell.


Jerry, I can't teach you anything about statistics, but for the benefit of others I'll point out that one of the interesting - even vital - figures needs to be derived; and that is the ratio of existing victims ("living with the virus") to new infections - in other words how fast the infection is growing.

Some very basic analysis shows that many of the areas (e.g. Asia or the Pacific) that had a relatively good position have an enormous growth rate in infection. The fact is, they haven't wanted to admit the problem, they've pretended it didn't exist, they've done nothing about it, and as a consequence infection is growing like wildfire. If they continue to do nothing for just a few more years they'll be guaranteeing that their position will reach the proportions of sub-Sahara Africa - particularly areas like Thailand and parts of the Philippines where the sex trade, international sex tours, and drug use have become established.

By contrast, the position of Australia and New Zealand is relatively good. How did we manage that? After all, Australia is just about THE centre of "gay" activity for the Asia Pacific region; and we had HIV and AIDS very early on (via the USA). Also the homosexual centres coincide with areas of large-scale drug use, so the infection got into the injecting drug-user population very early. Well, the simple fact is that our public-health people recognized the problem early on, conveyed the ramifications in terms of deaths and dollars to our politicians very well, and then launched very effective public education campaigns (read graphic and absolutely riveting advertisements, some but not all of them horrifying). They've pushed the value of safe sex on TV, they've busted some boundaries by showing how to use condoms on TV, they've pushed no-needle-sharing on TV, they've made it possible by introducing needle-exchange programs. They've tailored their campaigns to how people really act, rather than how they "ought" to act. Now, quite a few of us, me included, would wish things were different. They're not, and this approach has worked. It's saved countless lives, not just of homosexuals and injecting drug users, but also of their sexual partners, and THEIR sexual partners, and people who receive blood donations from those, and .... It's also saved a LOT of public health dollars, and that's not a trivial matter, because as we can see from sub-Sahara Africa, the situation has the potential to overwhelm any health system, and allow other diseases as well to reach epidemic proportions.

I'll leave the conclusions to be drawn by others, but we in Australia and New Zealand seem to be in relatively good shape, and that's how it was done.

Regards, Don Armstrong

 


Ed Hume says "You've been warning them about this:"

http://washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A4848-2000Nov29.html

Interestingly, the latest installment of David Feintuch's "Seafort Saga" bears on this as well.

Ed


And Mr. Dobbins exults "ain't it sweet?" to which I assuredly have 'no comment.'

http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=SALN&;d=t 

----------------------------------------------------------- Roland Dobbins 

 

 

TOP

 

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

TOP

Saturday, December 2, 2000

The following was a casual comment not sent for publication, but I thought it well worth doing so I got permission. Take it in context. The context is that Dr. Erwin has found an academic post, and thus hasn't any need for a "post doc". I remarked that when I was in graduate school no one ever heard of a "post doc". A Ph.D. was worth about 25% salary increase in the aerospace industry in my time. I never contemplated an academic career but I had plenty of offers. So I said:

>When I got out of grad school there was no such thing as a "postdoc", which >sounds an abombination. >

To which he replied:

It is an abombination. In American physics, new assistant professors are usually at least 40, because it takes 11 years to finish the PhD, and then they are facing 10 years of post-docs before any school will consider them for a tenure-track job. Ever wonder why science professors are so often out of touch with their students? The fact that I was doing a PhD while I taught computer science courses helped me to understand and reach my students.

I've been an (unpaid) post-doc for the last year at the bat lab, but I've been working full-time in addition as a senior software analyst ($90K). That's helped me maintain my self-image as a responsible adult. Most post-docs in psychology are paid $27-30K (NIH scale) and have crushing college loans and credit card debts built up. Sure, 80-hour weeks doing research is fun for many, but it defers becoming an adult, which will have its own satisfactions.

Why are we wasting this talent at jobs paying a subsistence wage? And most of these people will never teach--there is something seriously wrong with the American academic system.

On the other hand, the UK university system has its limitations. The Gummint insists that a PhD finish in 4 years. Even if they've done a 2-year MPhil, they won't be as well-trained as an American PhD. By UK standards, I've done almost three PhDs (algebraic topology, computational science, behavioral neuroscience).

End rant...

-- --- Harry Erwin, PhD, Computational Neuroscientist (modeling bat behavior) and Senior SW Analyst and Security Engineer. Sr lecturer in computing at the University of Sunderland (starts Jan). Webpage: <http://world.std.com/~herwin>


I find it interesting that the method used in Washington state is pretty much the one we use here in Canada for our federal elections, except that our ballots are counted by hand. In fact, I heard on election day that the layout of the ballot itself hasn't really changed in almost a hundred years. The same format and basic method is also used across the country, which helps in managing things.

Granted that we have a smaller population to deal with, and a winner by a large margin (so that any irregularities are easily overlooked), it's pretty hard not to be rather pleased we got our election over with quickly and smoothly (despite a few problems with voting stations not opening on time). I must say that from the perspective of a country with such close economic ties to the U.S., it's more than a little unnerving watching the presidential battle drag out.

Regards, Monty

Indeed. I have always had my suspicions about punched card systems. Far better a paper ballot with a big X. Those you can recount with some certainty. California says a one corner punch is not a punch. A dimple is not a punch. A two or three corner punch but "hanging" is a valid vote. Seems reasonable. Actually there are many possible rules that would work, but they ought to be agreed in advance, or agreed before counting starts, not changed every few hours.


Regarding my DSL line:

Dr. Pournelle:

I have a few customers all in the "trying to get DSL" stage. Perhaps one of them will actually get it.

The one live experience I have with DSL occurred 6 months ago. A customer had me drive from Cleveland to Columbus, Ohio to orchestrate the install. GTE had sent the hardware ahead of time. A Phone technician had already visited the site, leaving a card informing that the DSL line was installed. The customer received a postcard from GTE informing them the DSL line was "turned up" and ready for customer install.

I spent the whole day bouncing around tech support who spent most of the time coming up with reasons why the problem was on the customer end. (This seems to be an ugly trend where anyone's tech support works as quickly as possible to figure out who to pass the buck to...) The site had too many extensions and needed a splitter, or the site had an alarm system which interfered, etc. Finally I had spent enough time chasing down red herrings that I convinced GTE to check the CO. They discovered that the DSL pair was never connected in the CO. Murphy's Law dictates that it was an unmanned CO, so a technician would have to be dispatched, and that would take between 24 - 48 hours.

Two days later the customer received a call from GTE to inform them they they did not qualify for DSL since they were too far away from a CO. It's no wonder there seems to be a coming implosion of DSL providers. Covad is downsizing, and restated financials because they did not receive over $10 Million in ISP fees. Verizon is walking away from the NorthPoint merger, etc.

Thank you for your courtesy,

Richard Micko rmicko@clipperinc.com

When I left Los Angeles the light was still blinking. I'll call when I get home and see what "progress" has been made. I don't expect much. Roland hopes to get me some kind of wireless attachment piggybacked on his system but his antenna is too close to Van Nuys airport to be raised higher and at present height it sees Burbank (where it's supposed to be seen) but alas not my house.

 

 

TOP

 

 

This week:

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

read book now

TOP

Sunday, December 3, 2000

Over in view I mentioned the Heine / Schumann poem/song. This is not a very good translation. For the German, see

 http://www.orst.edu/instruct/ger341/grenad.htm 

I will see if I cannot find a better English, or do one myself; the rythms are wrong here, and so are some of the sentiments. My thanks to Al Somerville for finding this.

from http://www.articulate.de/heine/grena.htmlhttp://www.articulate.de/heine/gren a.html

The Grenadiers Text by Heinrich Heine (1797-1856). Translated into English by Joseph Massaad

deutsch - francais

After the Russian prison and its toil, Two French Grenadiers were returning home. As they reached the German soil, In despair they began to roam.. There they both heard news of infamy : That France has been lost, Beaten and destroyed the Great Army, Imprisoned, the Emperor, that hurts most!

On this miserable piece of news, The grenadiers cried together. The one said: " To suffer, I chose. My old wound will bleed forever "

The other replied : " Its all in vain, I wish to die with you.. But I have wife and kids to sustain. If I die, they will perish too "

I care not about kids nor wife, I have a greater need to satisfy. If hungry, let them beg and strive, My Emperor in prison, Oh my, oh my !

Should I now die, o brother, Please fulfill my last plea : Take be back to the land of my father, Bury me under a French tree.

The Cross of Honor, with its red band, Please place upon my breast, Lay the pistol in my hand, And the sword around my waist.

So I shall lie and listen under, Like a sentinel in a grave, Till I hear the canons thunder And gallops and whinings wave.

Then will my Emperor ride upon my tomb, And the swords will crash and rattle. I shall surge out of the earth's womb, To protect my emperor in the battle

The last verses are sung to the Marseilles. 

The last should be more like "Then rise will I armed, out of my grave, to give my Kaiser protection."  Translating great poets is not easy. Anyway, thanks.

And in fact here is a better translation, with German text as well as English. Thanks to subscriber David A. Todd.


Trent Telenko sends:

This is the first article I have found that captures the raw political passions I have been seeing develope in the Republican base.

The Republican rank and file has decided enmass to adopt the "Politics of Personal Destruction" as their own.

As the party of government, the Democrats are far more vulnerable to the politics of personal destruction. Something that Gingrich knew but Republicans fled after Oky City.

The Republicans plain don't care about that any more. They are going to use every Democratic trick they have seen in the Clinton era against the Democrats with more elan than the Democrats will know how to deal with.

http://www.observer.com/pages/frontpage6.asp 

I can't blame people for doing this. One takes only so much, particularly when it is predicated on the opponent being a gentleman about it. When the referee won't enforce the rules, ARE THERE ANY RULES ANY LONGER? But if the rules are off, the ALL RULES ARE OFF. That is the frightening thing. If you bring a knife to a fist fight, can you complain when the other guy says "Whoa!" and hauls out a gun?

Trent also sends this:

This is a background piece on the Republican protestors you are seeing on television.

These folks are planning a major "Freep" at Leiberman's home Dec 2.

URL: http://www.enterstageright.com/1200freepers.htm 

Lieberman complaining that Republicans are bringing in "outsiders" to Florida after Jesse Jackson started it can be fairly humorous. And says a LOT about Lieberman, the "conscience" of the Democratic Party.


Ed Hume says:

News item: Clinton for Chancellor of Oxford

They're seriously considering it, and the idea is popular with the faculty there.

All this moved my wife Sue to comment: "It brings a whole new meaning to the Peter Principle."

I can't possibly comment on that.


Dear Jerk Poornelle,

You stated last week that you wouldn't say anymore about the election...

How many bricks did the Democrats throw at Republicans? How disruptive was Jesse Jackson compared to your precious Republicans? You criticize Lieberman's complaints while saying Jesse Jackson started it. From the totally unacceptable behavior demonstrated by the rent-a-riot paid for by your great god, W, I would say your comments are shameful. I witnessed it first hand - I had to drive by it to get to work. It polluted the news all over the place. The Democrats have yet to resort to violence or intimidation. W's hired hooligans have been afraid of letting the uncounted ballots be examined by hand from the beginning and will stop at nothing to prevent a fair count. I guess since all rules are off, I am perfectly justified in subjecting any group carrying 'Sore Loserman 2000' signs to hand grenades and pipe bombs.

If you, or any of the ignorant idiots you showcase on your mailpage, ever bothered to do some simple research BEFORE opening your foolish traps, then maybe the significance of worn out plastic backing on the ballots would mean something to you (you did express concern on how so many ballots could be 'dimpled'.) But considering your history, real research coming from you or your ilk isn't likely.

By the way, I have yet to find any published material by Eric Raymond where he calls you any names. In fact, I don't ever recall reading anything by Eric that refers to you at all. You did say that he called you names too. When? Accusations like you made are called 'Libel'. Of course you already knew that, didn't you?

Get a grip... and a clue.

Darren; on behalf of; Darren Remington [Darren@netroenterprises.com]

Thank you for your reasoned comments. I probably don't have either grip or clue, but I fear I may not care much for your source either.


Dear Jerry,

Monty is correct when he says our Canadian ballots are easier to use, and that our leader is elected with such a huge majority so that recounts are not necessary. Except we don't actually vote for the Prime Minister, but his local representative, and some of those counts were within 150 votes (with hardly a recount demanded). Monty must be from Ontario, a province that has 103 Ministers of Parliament (with 101 voting for the incumbent party), out of 301 total MPs. I live in British Columbia, and our Prime Minister was confirmed as a winner 3 1/2 minutes after the polls closed. I wonder how many votes in BC were counted towards Mr. Chretien's victory? This leads to a terrible feeling of alienation here in the west, and it's confirmed when you compare federal funding to the provinces. Voter turnout is down across the country, and especially in the west. I'll admit that half the population is in Ontario, but that doesn't change the fact that the western provinces are vastly under funded. It gets even worse when you figure that the majority of voters were voting against the Liberals, but were fragmented by political differences.

I know that every time I vote in a Federal election, I want to punch something, though usually not a piece of paper!

It doesn't take a genius to make an X on a piece of paper, and I can't help but think of Mr. Heinlein's concept (from Starship Troopers) of a skill testing question being required prior to voting (I also remember military veterans were exempt from having to take the test!).

It's been almost a month since the US election, and still no clear winner (but some clear whiners!). The way I see it, neither candidate is acting presidential. I suggest that Bill Clinton gets his third term, and both Bush and Gore are disallowed from running in the future.

Regards,

Bill Grigg Kelowna BC

Actually Heinlein proposed a number of possible voter tests, some drastic, in his EXPANDED UNIVERSES, and even speculated on a system in which ONLY WOMEN were allowed to vote on the grounds they might be more sensible than men. But Robert was given to much speculation of many varieties.

Through most of history there have been some qualifications for being an elector. Some have been rather stringent. The Romans used possession of military equipment: Pedities of the First Class were those who owned, or could afford, full military equipment. Equites had horses. They went down through Pedites of the Fifth Class, who possessed or could afford a spear and helmet but nothing else. Finally was one century of Proletarians, who contributed nothing but progeny. Voting was by Centuries, and the Equites and the first two classes of Pedites had enough centuries to outvote the rest combined.

England had property qualifications. The French after the Revolution imposed the property qualification of three days wages at minimum wage. Some states have imposed literacy requirements. Those were abused in Jim Crow states, but the notion of requiring literacy assuming the test is fairly given is certainly arguable, as is the requirement that the voter pay some minimum tax, say the equivalent of a carton of cigarettes or a bottle of whisky. Again poll taxes have been abused but there is an argument in their favor provided they are applied fairly.

Nevil Shute proposed multiple votes: everyone gets one, you can have one more for paying taxes, veterans get another, you can get one for graduating from high school, and I forget the exact details of the fifth vote. The sixth was to be awarded as a badge of honor, something like the Medal of Freedom or the Congressional Medal of Honor. 

There are other such notions, the idea being to tame raw democracy. Aristotle proposed mixed institutions, some elected by people with property qualifications, some distributed lot. The "mixed form" intermediate between oligarchy and raw democracy has been elusive: it was thought to have been found in the United States Constitution, and perhaps so. On the other hand Franklin said "A Republic, Madam, if you can keep it." Republics are challenged not merely by monarchy and imperialist ambition. They can also be brought down by democracy.

"And there never was a democracy that did not commit suicide," was accepted by just about every one of the Constitutional Framers. Perhaps they were wrong.

Of course it makes no more sense to say "I rule because 50% plus one of the inhabitants regardless of their ability, intelligence, education, or industry chose me" than to say "I rule because your fathers swore to my father and you to me at my coronation."  No less, either. Neither is a very rational proposition. But we all know that, too.


To close the week let's take a lighter note: EVERQUEST

This is from the product manager in charge of my discussion forum when I used to run one on the old GE GENIE. Genie was wonderful. Alas, I sometimes drank when on line in those days, and not everything I said was something to be proud of. That problem you don't have any more. But Genie was a lot of fun. 

Everquest, Verant and 'customer service'

Jerry,

After an absence of a few days, I hit the Chaos Manor site to renew my annual subscription and what do I see but a subject near and dear to my heart.

As you know, I've been involved in massively multiplayer online games since the mid-80s, going back to the Golden Age of GEnie (And weren't those the days? Remember the intense, well-thought-out debates that used to break out spontaneously in your RoundTable? Of all the products in my charge at GEnie, yours was my favorite by far, due in large part to the intelligence of your RT regulars.).

 Believe me, there is nothing surprising or unique about Verant's sometimes clueless behavior toward their customers. It is endemic within the industry.

Verant is the most extreme case of the "You're in my world now!" Syndrome, a catch-phrase that also happens to be the motto for Everquest and which exquisitely points out the main problem here: The inmates are in charge of the asylum.

To that point, here's a clip from my Biting the Hand column titled 'Doomed to fail?' from August 25:

"3. Your development team should not be in charge of the live game.

Once the game is launched, customer-service people should be dictating fixes and changes to the dev team, or at the very least controlling the process. Unfortunately, it usually works out to be the reverse; the head of the dev team ends up being in charge of the "live" game.

This is a mistake; most dev teams should be gagged, muzzled, and forbidden direct contact with the players on the pain of a horrifying death to loved ones and idols. Dev teams are less concerned with the actual players' game experience, than with players experiencing the game in the way the team intended them to. After two to three years of development, they have a ton of emotional baggage concerning their "baby," and they tend to get downright hostile when someone plays it in a way the team did not intend. This leads to the nerfing--the willy-nilly changing of the design to stop unintended play patterns--and similar reactionary silliness we see in some of today's current MMOGs.

Such cowboy programming has caused more PR problems and player anger than any other single factor. To torture General Von Moltke's famous quote about war, no game design survives contact with the enemy. Players are inventive and curious; they will examine your game from all sides and play it in ways you never anticipated or imagined possible. To then punish them for finding new and interesting things about your game is unforgivable. I'm not talking about exploiting bugs to duplicating items or using cracks in the design to cause grief for other players; I'm talking about finding new strategies and tactics to get ahead. This is art, and should be rewarded as such.

The people making the decisions about these things shouldn't have a vested emotional interest; it makes it near impossible for them to be able to stand back and make rational decisions based on a combination of what is good for the players right now and what is good for the long-term health of the game."

(Note: For those so inclined, the whole column can be read at http://www.happypuppy.com/features/bth/bth%2Dvol9%2D22.html)

Verant's problem goes even deeper; many of the development team that used to run the game (there have been recent changes) came from the free-access text MUD universe, where using 'God' powers to lord it over the players and constantly fiddling with the code to match your own goals is the standard, not the exception. Someone forgot to tell them that EQ is also a for-pay service, not their personal playground. This hasn't seriously hit home in their pocketbook yet, simply because Verant had first-mover advantage in the market, being the first 3D, 1st person online role-playing developed by a major studio with a major budget.

And you are correct; competition will cure this behavior, one way or the other. At least 15 other professional MMOGs are in development, with three or four legitimate and well-funded efforts due out next year. Some of them will watch and learn from Verant's mistakes.

Think of it as evolution in action. (Sorry, just couldn't resist)

Best to you, Roberta and the gang,

Jessica jessica@gamebytes.com

This goes farther than I would, but the sentiments are understandable. I hope someone at Verant reads it; but do note, while I agree with the general direction of the remarks, and particularly that customer service oriented people should take over from developers, I don't have all that many complaints. I find Everquest enjoyable if sometimes irritating. My largest irritation is the attitude that because some players abuse disconnect in order to escape what would otherwise be certain death, disconnects that happen because the Everquest servers are overloaded must also be punished -- lest some player get away with something.

Now if this were player-vs-player I might agree; but when the monsters attacking are just non-player monsters, what harm does it do me if some other player resets to escape? Resetting the game is already punished by the fairly tedious log-on procedure. Why impose more? In particular I hate it when through Everquest's overload I get dumped and return to find I have lost all summoned objects and various other stuff, and have to start over. Why should I? But "You're in OUR world now..."

I suspect competition will change that. Meanwhile, I still find the game fun.


Regarding Neville Shute's voting scheme:

Dear Jerry (I hope I do not presume, but we've corresponded before);

A few comments on Sunday's mailbag:

First, while I, myself, am a "Yaller Dawg" Democrat, I have never found you less than fair in your treatment of those with differing views, no matter how far from yours, as long as they were clearly and intelligently expressed.

A couple of points: I think you despair too much over the current state of the Republic - it has great powers of self- repair. And I do think that both sides (make that all four sides) of this campaign have shown too much "schadenfreude" than is seemly in a civilized discourse.

If one may paraphrase Robt. E. Lee, It is well that politics is so terrible, else we might grow too fond of it".

Second, on Nevill Shute's voting proposals: there were seven. In addition to the ones mentioned, there were votes for living outside your country for a year, and for making a large amount of money (as a sign of practical competence). Time overseas in the armed forces would count as time outside the country.

I think you would qualify for many extra votes, Jerry. Glad to hear you're feeling better.

Hal Frank, DI - Chicago

Thank you. And of course I very much hope you are right. I probably read too much history. Certainly there are powers of self-repair. If Washington DC and all 537 elected Federal Politicians plus all their DC appointees were to vanish in an earthquake or a neutron weapon explosion, the country would go on. ADM would continue to buy food in Kansas and deliver it to the cities. Commerce would continue. The states would keep the highways open. The trains would run. It might take a while to get the airplanes flying again, but they would.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  TOP

 

 

birdline.gif (1428 bytes)